Lucas Biglia - 5.5

Made a few runs forward but was often thwarted by a pack of white shirts.

Maximiliano Meza - 6.5

Made a couple of threatening runs off the ball which were not found.

Angel Di María - 6

Provided a couple of crosses in the second half but was on the fringes for most of the game.

Lionel Messi - 7

Constantly looked for space and appeared his side's best route to goal. Poor penalty cost Argentina the win. 

Sergio Aguero – 7

Great finish and a few decent touches around the box. However, he was regularly smothered by the Icelandic defenders.

Subs

Ever Banega - 6 

Slightly more offensive than Biglia but still coundn't find a way through.

Cristian Pavon - 6.5

Forced a decent save from Halldorsson late on.

Gonzalo Higuain - N/A

Not enough time to give a fair rating.