Carl Valeri - 5

The Victory captain didn't have much impact on the match

Terry Antonis - 7

Was Melbourne's best, doing the best to control the midfield

James Troisi - 6

Hit the post early on with what seemed like a cross. The Newcastle defence paid a lot of attention to him afterwards fouling the Socceroo three times

Christian Theoharous - 5

Didn't quite have the impact he would have wanted in his starting debut. Was replaced by George.

Kosta Barbarouses - 7

Was denied by Duncan more than once and his speed got the best of his marker.

Besart Berisha - 5

It was an off night for the A-League's highest scorer. Missed many chances to equalise. He hasn't scored at McDonald Jones Stadium since October 2014.

SUBS

Matt Acton - 6

Made a rare appearance off the bench after Thomas was forced off. Made a valiant effort but couldn't prevent McGree from scoring a second.

Leroy George - 6

Returned from injury replacing Theoharous. Came on gave his side the service they were lacking in the first half.

Jai Ingham - N/A

Replaced Sanchez with just over 10 minutes of regular time remaining.